The Structure of
Unmasking the Meta-Levels of "Submodalities"
Armand Kruger, MA (Psych)
This book has been republished under the new title of
Another "makes you think" book by Michael Hall with Bobby
Bodenhamer! In reading this book about their views and thoughts on the
submodalities, I cannot but express appreciation for the work they are doing
in giving our vocabulary and tools in NLP the precision it deserves.
Did I write? A book on submodalities? Let me say immediately, if that
is the frame with which you would approach this book you will lose significant
pleasure and learning in the journey through the book. It is also an
epistemology of the submodalities, but with a but.
In this book you will also read some excellent and novel ways of
formulating the process and concept of genius and/or excellence. These fresh
ways of thinking about genius are with the applications and new ideas
around the submodalities. These applications are not only demonstrations, but
allow the sceptic to find ground for becoming convinced.
What stands out for me about this book is how they describe the process
of being human, and specifically the "best" of being human. As a
lecturer in NLP at three different universities I am confronted frequently
with two concerns students in psychology have when comparing NLP with some of
the current models about being human.
The first concern is that NLP is too simple, and people cannot be
reduced to their modalities. Secondly, when they mismatch NLP using their very
complex terminology (for which you definitely need a degree in psychology to
understand or one would be "out of the club"). In both cases I had
wished for a reference that I can recommend to them for reading about the
"enfolding complexity" of human experience.
These two authors have given me the reference which I was looking for. In the first three chapters they describe with many useful examples, how experience is a process within a process. The complexity of our experience is not in the theoretical or linguistic complexity with which we try to language our understanding. The complexity of experience is in the unfolding of the layers which presents itself like a swirling kaleidoscope. These two writers have said this for me in a very clear and precise way: to my mind this book is an excellent process description of experience.
And then, their first main theme: the "submodalities" which
are not sub but meta. I have started this book with a strong resistance. I do
trauma counselling using as a preferred method the "submodalities",
meaning I had a vested interest for them to stay the way I know them. Working
with trauma is challenging enough to not have the complication of
suddenly becoming consciously competent at what I have been doing like an
expert. The good news: submodalities are still understandable and useful! But
with a difference: they are the coding of meaning. The submodalities stand for
the meaning of the experience, and this explains why not for everybody
"close" means "good". Or, "small" is not
"safe". Or, "far away" is not "objective". The
submodalities are a very personal, customized way of representing or coding
meaning. Essentially, this is how people recognise meaning in their
experience: this is a description of an epistemology of meaning! Now that we
have this new thinking about the submodalities, what do we call them?
Calling the submodalities something different is less important than
what follows in the following 11 chapters: the applications of this thinking
about the submodalities. For the reader who stayed with the authors up to this
point (the shortcuts are reading the excellent summaries) you now have reached
the conclusion that the submodalities are highly personal coding of meaning,
and they are not "sub" to anything. The next chapters are both for
the applicator and the sceptic. The sceptic now has the opportunity to verify
their conviction for "what is new and valid". The applicator can
enjoy the action and add to their repertoire.
It is in the 11 chapters (from chapter 5 to 15) of applications in which the submodalities and meta-states are linked that one gets to appreciate the authors' willingness to share their information. Each one of the chapters refers to a meta-pattern and it's usage, how it may create a problem in experience, and an example, with the language patterns, of a personal application. These applications I suspect are what they teach on their programs, but here they give sufficient practical detail for the reader to make this information his/her own. And this characterises this book: a willingness to be more than intellectually persuasive.
They round this part of the book of with referring to some of the genius of Richard Bandler by citing examples of him unknowingly using "meta-stating patterns". Reading the chapter on Bandler (chapter 16) and the examples that they refer to, I got this real experience of "de ja vu". (The Dutch existentialist psychiatrist, J H van den Bergh referred to "metabletica" in his studies referring to how ideas happen simultaneously in different parts of the world. Jung called it synchronicity). Having just finished Robert Dilts' book on "Sleight of Mouth", he refers to a similar way of being influenced in his learning by Richard's genius in "framing" or "punctuating" experiences (1)
At the risk of saying it too simplistically, meta-stating is
punctuating or framing the experience in a way that determines the meaning of
the experience. (Enjoy how Hall and Bodenhamer describe this process using
foregrounding/backgrounding on page 95). Different words from different
experiences getting to the same intellectual place! That this is more than
coincidence is illustrated in chapter 17 where Hall et al cites numerous
examples of how the mental
processes of genius as described by Robert, are about making many
distinctions in different levels of experience. The name Hall et al gives the
process, namely meta-detailing is a very apt label for the process.
The book concludes with a theoretical wrap up that positions the meta-detailing
process as an integral part of how people experience, and deals with the
meaning in their own experience.
The book is not easy to get into, it is as if the authors got too
playful too soon. The repetition of their questioning of the submodalities in
the beginning was experienced as a hindrance, but in retrospect it was
necessary for me to get past my own resistance and conviction about the
submodalities. To get around it I found it useful to read the summaries of the
chapters and let them tease my inquisitiveness to want to read the detail.
Kruger is a registered clinical psychologist and international NLP-trainer
working from South Africa. He has trained with International NLP in the USA,
Switzerland and Austria. Kruger
specialises in modelling, the design and redesign of training to get peak
performing effectiveness during competence acquisition. He has published in NLP
World and Anchor
Point, and can be reached at armandk @ iafrica.com.
Robert Dilts (1999): Sleight of Mouth: The Magic of Conversational Belief Change. Meta Publications, Cupertino, California; page X, and 272 ff.
Structure of Excellence $30.00 + $5.00 S&H = $35.00Online Ordering — E-mail me a list of the products you want including your name, shipping address and telephone number and I will send you an invoice with the full cost of the products including shipping charges. Within the invoice that I will send you will be a link to PayPal where you can use your own PayPal account to pay for the products or you can use your own personal charge card. You may launch your e-mail program by clicking on the "Order Now" button to the right:
Shipping and Handling in the USA is generally $5 for the first book plus $2 per each additional book. For orders outside the USA, send an E-mail to us with the books you wish to order plus your shipping address and we will notify you promptly of the shipping charges. Air mail charges vary dramatically from country to country.
Pay with your own personal PayPal account.
Send your payment to:
You can contact me via phone, fax, email, or snail mail and I can accept your personal Master Card, Visa Card and/or Discover Card directly.
Send check or money order to:
Bobby G. Bodenhamer
1516 Cecelia Dr.
Gastonia, NC 28054