The Structure of
Unmasking the Meta-Levels of Submodalities
Judith Pearson, Ph.D.
This book has been republished under the new title of
Prepare to revise your thinking about submodalities, because L. Michael Hall and Bobby Bodenhamer, again, have produced a book that will enhance your understanding of NLP. What do submodalities have to do with excellence? By learning to modify our submodalities, we can better control cognitions and meanings, dismantle limiting beliefs, enlarge our range of possibilities, and awaken our personal genius. What makes this book remarkable is that Hall and Bodenhamer redefine submodality patterns as a previously unrecognized meta-domain of NLP. Submodality patterns are actually meta-level operations, requiring that we disengage from immediate experience to think about our internal representations in detail and modify the elements. This self-reflective consciousness can open pathways to states of excellence.
The Structure of Excellence is actually two books. Book I makes the case that submodalities take us to a meta-level regarding internal representations. It presents a model of excellence by defining the factors, processes, and states that contribute to genius, and shows how geniuses manage their thinking. Book II offers new NLP change patterns based on the relationship between submodalities and meta-states.
NLP is the science of taking a meta-position to individual human experience. With NLP we surmise that human functioning emerges from internal maps, constructed of sensory-based (VAKOG) representations. The structures and sequences of our maps are called strategies. Language is a higher order of representation; a meta-representational system. The Meta Model of language, the first meta-domain, allows us to articulate our maps and strategies. Meta-programs, a second meta-domain, describe the perceptual filters and personality variables that influence thinking and behavior. Meta-states, a third meta-domain, describe how we perceive and feel about our own thinking and feelings.
Representational systems are the building blocks of our models of the world (maps). Submodalities (a term coined by Richard Bandler in the 1980s) are the details that reveal the "code" of the building blocks; a structural blueprint of internal experience. When we examine our submodalities we are in a fourth meta-domain, what the authors call Meta-detailing. Hall and Bodenhamer propose that submodalities are not "sub" to anything. Instead, examining submodalities is a meta-level process.
The ability to "go meta to" direct personal experience is the structure of genius. NLP began as a study of the structure of therapeutic genius, as practiced by Erickson, Satir, and Perls. Bandler and Grinder found that, with the Meta Model, they could inquire about the distortions, deletions, and generalizations of perceptual/conceptual maps and representational systems to understand how people create empowering states.
"Geniuses operate from a different paradigm, a different way of perceptually filtering and sorting things, from a different conceptual reality and from a more advanced way of using his or her (sic) nervous system. Those individuals who perform excellence at higher levels or in new ways also tend to use different mental-and-emotional strategies." (p. 30)
Typically, we don't experience submodalities consciously. We usually don't ask ourselves questions about the structure of our internal representations. To examine our submodalities, we must go meta to our representations and doing so changes the frame. Now we are observing our thoughts. To do so, we necessarily operate in a meta-state.
So what does this have to do with genius? A genius operates from a dual focus, recognizing key differences, while simultaneously maintaining a "big picture" or overall frame of meaning. According to Hall and Bodenhamer, geniuses have:
To develop the quality of genius in any skill one brings "higher level frames of awareness to bear on the quality level of the representational systems. Genius arises from and exists as a meta-level state of consciousness...[and] inherently involves a flexibility of consciousness."
Submodalities are not lower level components of internal representations. They capture the qualities and properties of internal representations. They cannot exist as separate from our representations. They are higher order processes that shape representations. Submodalities derive from understandings and concepts, not vice versa. Yet NLP has operated as though submodalities and meanings form a two-way street (i.e., change the submodalities and the meaning changes automatically). Yet, in practice, this method has not always worked. Hall and Bodenhamer state that submodality change patterns work "only when meta-frames are set."
Thus, submodality shifts are effective when, in going meta to the internal representation, one also accesses meta-states conducive to change. The primary contribution of this book is that it debunks the long-held premise that changes in submodalities, in and of themselves, result in state changes.
"We now realize that if a submodality shift works, it works because it has activated some meta-level structure." (p. 208)
While Book I is theoretical, Book II is practical, presenting six new NLP pattern groupings that can change experience at a meta-level:
"We will not find these higher level and layered phenomena (i.e., beliefs and meanings)... amendable (sic) to mere 'submodality' shifts. The only exception...occurs when we use a 'submodality' quality, distinction, or feature in a way so that it represents, or stands for, some higher level symbol. Thus, if 'a black and white picture' represents the meta-level concept of 'Not Real,' and 'a picture in color' represents the meta-level concept of 'Real,' then we could bring this 'submodality' feature to bear...so that it sets the frame of 'Real' and thereby turn a mere 'thought'...into a 'belief.'" (p. 220)
Next, Book II gives three new Meta-Pattern Applications for excellence:
The authors invite us to refer to submodality shifts as Meta-distinction Patterns. They then review Bandler's work in submodalities to show that much of his success was in his ability to meta-state the changes people wanted. Robert Dilts (Strategies of Genius, Volumes I, II, and III, Meta Publications, 1994-1995) pointed out that the observation of submodalities could be called "meta-detailing;" paying attention to the details from a meta-position. This is "the essence of genius,"---moving from the general to the specific and back again.
NLP helps us reach meta-cognitions by getting us out of content so that we focus on the context or structure of thought and behavior. Meta-thinking means examining the "structure or process nature of our thoughts." Thus, we enter the meta-domains of NLP; the Meta Model, Meta-programs, and Meta-detailing (submodalities). Submodality distinctions (color, location, or brightness, for example) stand for higher level concepts such as past/future or old/new. Examining and commenting on submodalities are dissociative processes that de-intensify emotions and take us to a "higher frame of reference" (a Meta-state). The structure of excellence is found in the ability to go meta to one's thoughts, and to set higher frames of meaning that organize, govern, and support desired outcomes.
Hall and Bodenhamer are familiar names to readers of Anchor Point. They have co-authored a number of books and articles that bring new understandings and approaches to the practice of NLP. They are both masterful NLP trainers and geniuses in their own right.
The Structure of Excellence is not a light read. It is well-researched, complex, thought-provoking and best digested in small chunks. It is full of new ideas and concepts about submodalities and the cognitive process of going meta to our thoughts and feelings. The book is an in-depth analysis of the mental ability of the genius---the ability to simultaneously attend to details, maintain a framework, meta-state the process, and take varying perceptual positions to the work at hand. The Structure of Excellence is the best book available on submodalities and one that NLP practitioners and trainers will definitely want for their personal libraries.
To purchase The Structure of Excellence (ordering information below) and additional works by L. Michael Hall and Bobby Bodenhamer contact:
L. Michael Hall, Ph.D.
Empowerment Technologies: E.T. Publications
P.O. Box 9231
Grand Junction, CO, 81501 USA
Phone: (970) 523-7877
Judith E. Pearson, Ph.D. is a Master Practitioner and Certified Trainer of NLP. She is a Licensed Professional Counselor practicing in Springfield, Virginia.
To contact Judith:
E-mail: judy @ engagethepower.com
Web Site: www.engagethepower.com
Mailing Address: 5417-C Backlick Road, Springfield, VA 22151
©2000 Judith E. Pearson, Ph.D.. All rights reserved.
Structure of Excellence $30.00 + $5.00 S&H = $35.00Online Ordering — E-mail me a list of the products you want including your name, shipping address and telephone number and I will send you an invoice with the full cost of the products including shipping charges. Within the invoice that I will send you will be a link to PayPal where you can use your own PayPal account to pay for the products or you can use your own personal charge card. You may launch your e-mail program by clicking on the "Order Now" button to the right:
Shipping and Handling in the USA is generally $5 for the first book plus $2 per each additional book. For orders outside the USA, send an E-mail to us with the books you wish to order plus your shipping address and we will notify you promptly of the shipping charges. Air mail charges vary dramatically from country to country.
Pay with your own personal PayPal account.
Send your payment to:
You can contact me via phone, fax, email, or snail mail and I can accept your personal Master Card, Visa Card and/or Discover Card directly.
Send check or money order to:
Bobby G. Bodenhamer
1516 Cecelia Dr.
Gastonia, NC 28054